The Cost of Deception in the Bible and Today

David served in King Saul’s court and became famous for defeating the Philistine giant Goliath. But as David’s popularity grew, Saul became jealous and began pursuing him to kill him.

While on the run, David arrived at Nob and sought help from Ahimelech the priest. Ahimelech came out trembling. Why, he asked, was David traveling alone? David did not tell him that he was fleeing for his life. Instead, he claimed to be on a secret mission for Saul (1 Samuel 21:1–2).

That lie became part of a terrible chain of events. Doeg the Edomite saw David at Nob and later reported the encounter to Saul. Saul ordered the priests killed. Doeg killed eighty-five priests and put the town of Nob to the sword. Ahimelech’s son Abiathar escaped and told David what had happened.

Saul ordered the slaughter, and Doeg carried it out. Yet David acknowledged that he had known Doeg would report seeing him and that his actions had contributed to the tragedy (1 Samuel 22:6–23).

The question lingers:
What weight does David’s lie carry?

We do not know why David lied. Perhaps he feared Ahimelech would refuse to help. Perhaps he thought the priest would be safer if he did not know Saul was pursuing him. But Ahimelech was already trembling, and David’s story left him without the information he needed to understand the danger.

What if someone lies to save his own life without placing anyone else in danger?

Would that change the answer?

Is it ever right to lie?
Scripture’s answer requires us to take both its call to truthfulness and its difficult stories seriously.

The Bible Calls Us to Tell the Truth

Before considering the difficult cases, we need to hear Scripture’s clear teaching. God commands us not to bear false witness against our neighbor (Exodus 20:16). Proverbs says that lying lips are an abomination to the Lord (Proverbs 12:22). Paul tells believers to put away falsehood and speak truthfully to one another (Ephesians 4:25; Colossians 3:9).

Paul’s instruction is more than a rule about what Christians should say. In Ephesians 4, he tells believers to put off the old self and put on the new self, created after God’s likeness (Ephesians 4:22–24). Then he tells them to put away falsehood (verse 25). Those who belong to Christ are called to become truthful people. We do not earn salvation by telling the truth, but a changed relationship with Christ should change the way we speak.

God’s call to truthfulness does not end at the church door. Our neighbors rely on our words. Deception can take away another person’s ability to make an informed choice. Ahimelech helped David without knowing why Saul might regard that help as treason.

Yet other biblical accounts make the question harder than simply saying, “Never withhold the truth, whatever happens next.”

What About Rahab and the Hebrew Midwives?

When the king of Jericho sent men to find the Israelite spies, Rahab hid them. She told the king’s men that the spies had already left and suggested they pursue them. The spies were still in her home (Joshua 2:1–7).

Rahab risked her life to protect them. Later, Hebrews commends her faith, and James points to her receiving and helping the messengers as evidence of that faith (Hebrews 11:31; James 2:25). Those passages praise what she did for the spies. They do not explicitly say that every word she spoke to the king’s men was right.

The Hebrew midwives faced an evil command of their own. Pharaoh ordered them to kill newborn boys, but they feared God and let the children live. When Pharaoh questioned them, they gave him an explanation. Exodus says God blessed the midwives because they feared Him, though the passage does not settle whether their answer was entirely truthful (Exodus 1:15–21).

Still, Christians disagree about whether protecting innocent life can justify saying something false. Some believe we must never lie, even under that threat. Others believe deception can be justified to keep an innocent person from being killed. Rahab’s story makes us face the question, but it does not give us a simple rule for every situation.

The Lies We Are More Likely to Tell

Consider a modern example closer to home. A woman I will call Erin was dating three young soldiers when she became pregnant. She did not know which man was the father. She singled out the one from a wealthy family and allowed him to believe he was the only man she had been with.

He proposed, and wedding plans moved quickly. But he was blessed with a discerning grandfather who had the courage to insist on a paternity test before the wedding. The test showed that the young soldier was not the father, and the wedding was canceled.

Did Erin tell an outright lie? Perhaps not in those exact words. Did she deliberately mislead him about something that would change his life? Absolutely!

Her story reminds me that truthfulness involves more than finding words I can technically defend. We can deceive through silence, a partial account, or an answer carefully designed to leave someone with a false impression.

The question is more searching than “Did I say something technically false?” What did I intend the other person to believe, and what might it cost them to believe it?

What Does God See?

God sees both our words and our hearts. He knows when we are protecting someone vulnerable, when we are afraid, and when we are dressing up self-interest as a good intention. A worthy goal does not automatically make every means of reaching it right. Nor does a technically accurate sentence make us truthful if we intend someone to believe what we know is false.

I am still working through the hardest question: whether a lie told to save an innocent life can be right before God. I believe we should protect the innocent, and I cannot treat a murderer’s demand for information as though it were an ordinary request from a neighbor. At the same time, I want to take seriously God’s repeated call to speak truthfully.

David’s story makes us ask whom our words might endanger. Rahab’s makes us ask what we would do to protect someone threatened by evil. Erin’s makes us ask whether we are hiding behind the claim that we “never actually said” something false.

Perhaps the most honest place to begin is with the lies for which we have no good excuse—the ones we tell to look better or escape accountability. Before I try to settle the hardest case, I need to ask myself a simpler question:

Am I willing to tell the truth when telling it will cost me something?

Your comments are welcome – please review House Rules. 
To protect your anonymity use a pseudo name.
Your email will not be seen, but a fake email is ok too.